Menu
For the Little Shackees
Whitty Shark
Vanilla Custard smothered with Cookies ‘n’ Crème and Gummi Sharks
Shark Bait
Vanilla Custard smothered with Cookie Dough and Gummi Sharks
Happy Shack
Vanilla Custard with Sprinkles for the Hair, Cookie Dough for a Nose, Candy Eyes, and a Gummy Worm for a Smile
Kids Cup or Cake Cone
Choose your Shack Scoop
Our Fresh Vanilla, Chocolate, or Flavor of the Day
Cup
Cake Cone
Waffle Cone
Dipped Waffle Cone
Create your own Flavor - "Shackit"
In a cup we mix your choice of one topping to any Shack flavor to create your own unique flavor.
Mini, Small, or Regular
Island Favorites
Served as a Shack Sundae or “Shackit”
Mini, Small, or Regular
Shack Attack
Reese's Cup®, Chocolate Syrup, and Peanut Butter
Sea Turtle
Hot Fudge, Hot Caramel, and Pecans
Sanibel Lighthouse
Chocolate Covered Waffle Pieces, Butterfinger, and Hot Caramel
Muddy Mangroves
Mocha, Cookies ‘n’ Crème, and Hot Caramel
Beach Party
Pineapple, Coconut, Banana, and Macadamia Nuts
Captiva Sunset
Brownie Bites, Hot Fudge & Chopped Nuts
Salty Shack
Sea Salt Caramel and Brownie Bites
Green Flash
Mint and Chocolate Flakes
Island Split
Sliced Banana with Strawberry, Chocolate Syrup, Pineapple, Whipped Topping, and a Cherry
Love Shack
Warm Brownie with Hot Fudge and Whipped Topping (served as a sundae)
Periwinkle Perfection
Butterscotch and Pecans
Sea Grapes
Dark Bing Cherries & Dark Chocolate Flakes
Conch Crunch
Cookies-n-Creme, Cookie Dough & Chocolate Syrup
Short Stack
Shortcake & Strawberries (served as a sundae)
Shack Shakes
Small or Medium
Make it a Malt | Add additional toppings
Shack Floats
Root Beer or Orange Crush
Shack Toppings
Favorites
Butterscotch, Chocolate Flakes, Chocolate Syrup, Hot Caramel, Hot Fudge, Marshmallow, Mint, Mocha, Peanut Butter, Sea Salt Caramel
Fruits
Apple, Banana, Banana Syrup, Bing Cherry, Blueberry, Pineapple, Raspberry, Strawberry
Candies
Butterfinger, Cookies 'n' Creme, Gummy Sharks, Heath Bar, M&M's, Reese's Cup, Snickers
Nuts, Etc.
Almonds, Cashews, Chopped Nuts, Macadamias, Malt Powder, Pecans, Spanish Peanuts, Toasted Coconut
Extras
Candy Eyes, Maraschino Cherry, Rainbow Sprinkles, Whipped Topping
Bites
Brownie, Cheesecake, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Chocolate Covered Waffle Cone Pieces
Take Home
Pints - Variety of Flavors
Sand Dollars - Variety of Flavors
Chocolate covered Bananas
Speciality Chocolate Bananas
Freeze Pop
Italian Ice
Water
Bottled Soda
Cakes & Specialty Cakes
Vegan/Dairy Free Pints & Cups
The Doggy Shack
For the pups
Food - Delicious and Quick
Pulled Pork BBQ and Shredded Chicken Sandwiches - $6.00
Hot Dogs - $3.50 or Two for $6.00 (K/M, Relish & Onion--Free;
Chili/Cheese .75 each, Sauerkraut .50 extra)
Daily Flavor Calendar
With our many quality toppings, we have unlimited flavors at The Shack. We offer a new daily flavor made with our favorite blends of delicious ingredients. Vanilla and chocolate frozen custard are freshly churned throughout the day, and customers may create their own flavor by selecting a wide variety of toppings and mixing together for a unique creation. Creating your own flavor is what we call a Shackit…we always say we want everyone to Shackit on Sanibel! Customers can also choose from our selection of Island Favorites- combinations of ingredients we think are delicious together and we know you will agree!